I use a Logitech Freedom, and love the precision and the button layout. I've had it for about 9 months and have had no reliability issues at all.
If you don't like the wireless aspect, they now make a wired version. It looks like the same stick (so I would expect the same kind of precision and durability) but I think it's cheaper. As you can see, many people dig the Saitek stuff, and their prices are very competitive. On the high-side, CH makes the primo-stuff, but it's VERY pricey.
There used to be a joystic review thread around here...hmmmm.
Aha. Here they are:
Freedom Road-test Follow-upHow do You Interface with MW?This is the second time I've revived the Joystick threads because of a new question. Should we pin something onthis topic?